Cleaver Props and Nose Cones: No Use on Slower Boats

 

Cleaver prop
Leave the Cleaver-style props and sleek nose cones for boats that are already fast, because odds are they won’t make your family boat any faster. Photo: Mercury Racing.

Look through the listings on BoatTrader.com long enough and you’ll find a recreational boat fitted with a Cleaver-style propeller or a sleek nose cone on the leading edge of the stern drive. (For background, see Mercury Racing CNC Cleaver: Props for the Props.)  The owner will tell you the boat is faster with that equipment. Hogwash. Here’s why.

Cleaver-style propellers work best on 100-plus-mph boats with surfacing drives, which means only half the propeller is in the water when the boat is at speed. For recreational boats with submerged drives, cleaver props are incredibly inefficient, particularly at low speeds and in reverse.

“Cleaver propellers supercavitate even if they’re submerged,” said Dr. Christopher Kent, assistant professor of ocean engineering at Florida Institute of Technology in Melbourne, Fla. “You don’t need to be up near the surface to have the entire suction back [front of the propeller] encapsulated in a bubble.”

That cavitation bubble makes for increased slip and vibration, which makes you go slower. Propeller designs for recreational boats have come a long way in the last 10 years. You’re much better off using a modern, stainless round-ear propeller, which can provide increased top speed without sacrificing efficiency.

Likewise, the rhetoric is that nose cones and lower gear cases with built-in nose cones—also known as crescent-leading-edge designs—increase a boat’s performance because of their sleek shape and sharp leading edge. Although it is true that a sharper leading edge can decrease drag, it’s also true that adding a nose cone can lengthen the gear case front to rear, which increases drag, thereby negating any benefits.

“If your boat doesn’t have the horsepower/hull combination to run in excess of 85 mph with the gear case it has, a CLE gear case will actually make it run a fair bit slower because of increased drag,” said Jack Litjens, Mercury Marine’s competitive intelligence manager. “This type of gear case is for a very specific application.”

So, if you are looking at a garden-variety runabout with those items on it, and the current owner claims it makes the boat faster, well, you’ll know better.

 

Written by: Brett Becker

Brett Becker is a freelance writer and photographer who has covered
the marine industry for 15 years. In addition to covering the ski boat
and runabout markets for Boats.com, he regularly writes and shoots for
BoatTrader.com. Based in Ventura, Calif., Becker holds a bachelor’s
degree in journalism and a master’s in mass communication from the
University of Central Florida in Orlando.

Related

A purpose-built ski boat has the engine in the middle. This helps the boat get out of the hole fast and provides a flatter wake for the skier.
Ski and Wakeboard Boat Pros and Cons
Category: Boating

Boats for waterskiing, wakeboarding, and wake surfing are purpose-built and represent an intense but...