Bayliner vs. Sea Ray

Buying a boat is a lot like — well, it’s a lot like any other major purchase you’ve ever had to make. The fact that this is a purchase that isn’t a necessity means that the factors that you consider are going to vary from one situation to the next. Bayliner and Sea Ray are two very popular brands that are working hard to constantly design the next best thing in boating, and will certainly give you plenty to consider. Some of the top items you’ll want to keep in mind include:

Both of these brands are owned by Brunswick, which allows them to cover the breadth of the parent company’s audience with everything from family-friendly budget Bayliners to fully-customized luxury Sea Ray models that pull out all the stops. And, of course, you’ll also find just about every option in between when you’re shopping these two brands. How do they stack up when compared side by side, though? What kind of features does each offer? Why is their construction worthy of notice? What other design features can be found? And, of course, the question that everyone wants to know: how much will each brand cost.

bayliner versus sea ray
Bayliner and Sea Ray are two well-known brands that play in similar waters. Photo (top) via Union Marine, photo (bottom) via Sea Ray Boats.

Bayliner Boat Construction Vs. Sea Ray Boat Construction

The biggest distinction between Bayliner and Sea Ray when it comes to construction is the approach. Bayliner takes a more minimalist approach, while Sea Ray focuses on building out as much as it can to deliver premium features and other perks. Of course, for Bayliner, minimalist doesn’t mean stark. Their construction is effective, offering high-quality materials that are durable. Bayliner shifted to wood-free, all-composite construction years ago. Stringers are fiberglass, and Bayliners are NMMA-certified and meet all American Boat and Yacht Council standards on top of meeting USCG requirements. There is some use of plastic parts, and some hatches that are painted on the underside rather than being fully finished. Still, though they may not be as fancy as some, these parts are remain fully functional and sturdy and help Bayliner keep cost in check.

hatch on a bayliner vr6
Though some parts like hatches may not be as fancy as they are on more expensive boats, they’re completely functional and sturdy. Photo via Union Marine.

Sea Ray offers all-composite construction that is durable, NMMA-certified, and utilizes premium components like vinylester resin, stainless-steel fittings, PVC rubrails with stainless-steel inserts, and tempered tinted glass windshields. Fit and finish on Sea Rays is generally exceptional. Most boats in their lineup also incorporate the “Quiet Ride” technology, which utilizes construction techniques like filling voids with foam, acoustically insulating multiple areas of the boat, and integrating routered-in gaskets with positive-locking latches on hatches and doors, to provide a quieter ride with fewer vibrations. Also note that Sea Ray integrates more major components (such as swim platforms) as opposed to bolting on additional pieces and parts. Sea Ray also backs their sport boat construction up with a stem-to-stern five-year warranty topped by a limited lifetime warranty of the hull and deck for the original owner.

From the steering wheel to the seats, you’ll find premium parts on a Sea Ray. Photo via Sea Ray Boats.

Bayliner Design Traits Vs. Sea Ray Design Traits

Bayliner’s design is modern and focused, but many models (which range from 15 to 24 feet) are more basic than their competition. Some people appreciate the minimalist design, as well as the budget-friendly selection that fits every family, not just those who are “rich enough” to afford a premium luxury boat. The designs they make include deck boats, center console boats, and bowrider runabouts. Most are outboard designs, but Bayliner does also offer some models in stern drive versions. One of Bayliner’s missions across the board is to provide as much room as possible in their boats, which has resulted in what they term the “BeamForward” design. Essentially, this just means Bayliner brings the full beam of the boat as far forward as possible, resulting in more interior space in areas like the bow cockpit.

bayliner element e18
Bayliner’s innovative and unique M-Hull design, seen here on an Element E18, provides surprising stability. Photo via Aloha Marine Center.

Bayliner is also known for some innovative thinking in their designs, best evidenced by the “M-Hull” seen on the Element models. From the bow the hull has an M-shaped form, which maximizes stability both while running and when at rest. It’s particularly effective on small models which might otherwise be rather tippy, but in fact have impressive stability.

Sea Ray likes to show off its style, designed and marketed much like modern luxury cars. Each model is styled and designed with a deep understanding of consumer needs and desires, and the company features a staff of engineers and designers, as well as naval architects, that ensure that every single part of a Sea Ray looks and feels seamless and easy to enjoy. Sea Ray also spends a lot of time creating prototypes and testing different models to develop their designs. They have a much wider range than Bayliner, including over two dozen models from 19 to 40 feet. These include bowriders and runabouts, deck boats, sport boats, wake boats, coupes, and sport cruisers. Sea Ray also builds many of their models in both outboard and stern drive versions.

sea ray slx 400 ob
Sea Ray’s lineup is extensive, and goes all the way up to the 40 foot SLX 400 OB seen here. Photo via Sea Ray Boats.

Bayliner Performance vs. Sea Ray Performance

Bayliner tends to offer basic, less expensive models with lower-power engines, although some of their larger models do offer hat-stripping performance. While most of their boats aren’t going to hit blistering top speeds or help you win that tournament where engine power is involved, they are going to deliver the performance that you need to have a good time on the water with family and friends. Of course, just how spectacular the performance is for any given model will depend on what powerplant you opt for. Bayliner boats are sold with Mercury Marine outboards and MerCruiser stern drives, and the range available can be quite broad. Their 22 foot deck boat, for example, can be had in stern drive (DX2250) or outboard models (DX2200) with powerplants ranging from 150 all the way up to 250 horsepower.

bayliner dx2250
Some Bayliner models, like this DX2250, are available with a very wide range of power systems and performance will vary accordingly. Photo via Marine Center of Indiana.

Sea Ray allows customers to choose between standard outboard motors or sterndrive systems that provide increased power and speed for all kinds of boating activities. The SLX series features luxury designs and performance, with more than a handful of models that are tailored for luxury, speed, and fun on the water, no matter which motor you choose. And in some cases, you can really pack on the power. Remember that SLX 400? With triple Mercury Verado 300 outboards on the transom it can break the 50-mph mark.

mercury outboards
Performance is a highlight on many Sea Ray models, especially those which can really pack on the power. Photo via Sea Ray Boats.

Bayliner Cost Vs. Sea Ray Cost

Bayliner starts the pricing battle with numbers that are ideal for those looking for an affordable way to have a good time on the water. New boat prices start under the $20,000 mark for complete boat-motor-trailer packages and even their most expensive boats (at the time of this publishing) carry an MSRP under $70,000. In fact, Bayliners are, foot-for-foot, some of the most easily afforded boats on the market today.

Sea Ray, on the other hand, has boats with pricing ranging up into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. The old adage applies: you get what you pay for. And in the case of Sea Ray, you’re getting a premium product — so you have to expect to pay a premium.

The Bottom Line

Bayliner and Sea Ray both have their pros and cons, both have high standards of production, and both sell a product that they stand behind. With so many great features and models to choose from, it’s really going to boil down to what you’re looking for in a new boat. While we can tell you that both brands offer some great points in this comparison, we can’t make the final call. That’s going to be up to you. So, take the time to get to know these two brands and see what they can offer you in the way of performance, construction, and price to get you out on the water in a new craft you can call your own.

See Bayliner boats for sale on Boat Trader.

See Sea Ray boats for sale on Boat Trader.

Written by: Valerie Mellema

Valerie Mellema is a writer, published author and avid bass angler who lives on the shores of Lake Fork in East Texas — the top bass lake in Texas and the fifth in the nation. For the past 10 years, she and her husband have enjoyed the pontoon boat lifestyle while fishing a lake that not only has bass but beautiful wildlife as well. She holds a BS in Agribusiness/Equine Business and regularly contributes articles to boats.com, YachtWorld and Boat Trader.

Related

boat running with propellers
Boat Propellers Simplified
Category: Boat Engines
Propellers can be complicated—here are the basics every boater should know.